Story Stocks^®

CarMax (KMX) is under pressure after posting a sizable top- and bottom-line miss in its Q2 (Aug) report. EPS missed by the widest margin in 11 quarters, while revenue fell 6% yr/yr to $6.6 bln, the first decline in four quarters and steepest in five.

• Comp sales fell 6.3% vs. +8.1% in Q1, snapping a 4-qtr growth streak. Each month weakened sequentially, though September is trending slightly better but still down yr/yr.
• Total retail and wholesale units fell 4.1% yr/yr to 338,031. Retail declined 5.4% to 199,729, while wholesale slipped 2.2% to 138,302.
• CarMax Auto Financing (CAF) income dropped 11% to $103 mln as a 26% yr/yr increase in loan loss provisions offset margin gains. Allowance rose to 3.02% from 2.76% in Q1.
• Management had expected growth in CAF but now sees flat to down results as as greater than anticipated losses from the 2022-23 vintages mount.
• The problem: inventory was ramped in Q1 on tariff pull-forward expectations, which did not materialize in Q2. This led to greater depreciation and less competitive pricing in Q2. To drive sell-through, KMX cut retail margins and slowed vehicle purchases.

Briefing.com Analyst Insight

This was a tough quarter for KMX and raises questions about execution. The tariff-driven pull-forward in Q1 did not repeat, leaving the company with excess inventory and reduced pricing power, a key concern in a consumer sensitive category. At the same time, credit deterioration in CAF is hurting results after management had signaled growth. Although September trends show some improvement, the softness implies a more prolonged reset, keeping investor sentiment cautious.