Story Stocks^®

Paychex (PAYX -1%) investors start to check out today following a Bloomberg report noting that the payroll, human capital management (HCM), and HR services provider is discussing purchasing its smaller competitor Paycor (PYCR +23%). While no financial details have been leaked, shares of PYCR are bouncing to their best levels since October 2023, giving it a market cap of over $4.0 bln. Even though PAYX is slipping today on the news, if PYCR is acquired for around $4.0 bln, PAYX would be paying a reasonable 5.5x projected FY24 sales. The uncertainty surrounding the transaction details is likely producing modest profit-taking in PAYX today, especially following the stock's roughly +20% gain since July 2024 lows.

• While there is no confirmation of a takeover, the deal would be a good fit for both firms. PYCR is growing at around four times the rate of PAYX, which has been delivering mid-single-digit revenue growth over the past few years. Underpinning PYCR's healthy growth rate is its refreshing, alternative platform that helps lure customers away from legacy technology, such as that offered by PAYX, as well as other established giants in the industry, like Automatic Data (ADP).
• PYCR is focused on the mid-market, where roughly 50% of the total HCM market lies. By adding PYCR, PAYX takes a meaningful leap forward in one of its core long-term objectives: bolstering its middle-market HCM business. In fact, in Q2 (Nov), mid-market was a notable area of growth for PAYX as businesses in this section of the industry largely expressed optimism about 2025, with hiring intentions in November bouncing to the highest level since late 2023.
• PAYX mentioned last month that its M&A pipeline might be the largest it has seen in years as players in the industry return toward rational realizations about value, prompting companies to discuss more potential deals. PAYX added that it would be focused on opportunities that would add scale in new or existing markets, such as where it has been allocating capital, i.e., mid-market. PAYX also commented that it is looking for new growth platforms adjacent to its platform, making PYCR a perfect choice.
• Consolidation is becoming more likely as competitors begin to reach par with each other regarding capabilities across the HCM suite. Also, consolidating such a fragmented industry, where numerous companies offer HR and payroll services, can be beneficial to customers looking to avoid the hassle of constantly switching vendors to find a better price or more comprehensive tools. PAYX has touched on this in past earnings calls, noting that clients are increasingly interested in building long-term relationships with their HCM partners.

As a competing HR and payroll services provider, PYCR's business and clientele complement PAYX nicely. With U.S. employment remaining durable despite encountering numerous economic challenges over the past couple of years, setting up for a hiring rebound, PAYX could acquire PYCR at a ripe moment.