Story Stocks^®

Helen of Troy (HELE -30%) sinks to decade lows today after economic headwinds picked up during Q1 (May), proving to be the personal care and houseware product manufacturer's Achilles heel, leading to wide earnings and revenue misses alongside slashed FY25 (Feb) guidance. With no apparent signs of a recovery in discretionary spending, HELE, which owns Oxo and Vicks, was up against low expectations ahead of its Q1 report. Nevertheless, investors did not anticipate the extended cumulative effects of inflation weighing as considerably as they did on the end consumer during Q1.

While some of HELE's brands could be classified as non-discretionary, most products are not critical for daily functions. At the same time, HELE competes in categories heavily exposed to competitors, including name brands and private labels. HELE is also dependent on third-party retailers, with Amazon (AMZN), Walmart (WMT), and Target (TGT) comprising 40% of its FY24 revenue, which display HELE's competitors prominently, possibly nudging consumers toward alternatives, particularly those with lower price points.

• These characteristics culminated in a dismal Q1 report. HELE registered adjusted EPS of $0.99, its lightest quarter and first earnings miss in five years. The miss was particularly frustrating given that HELE is amid a restructuring plan -- Project Pegasus -- which targets annualized operating profit improvements of $75-85 mln by the end of FY27, with 35% of savings to be achieved in FY25.
• Sales falling by 12.2% yr/yr to $416.8 mln primarily contributed to HELE's steep bottom-line miss. While Beauty & Wellness was the main drag, Home & Outdoor also declined. In Beauty, hair products lagged, a similar issue that peers faced in recent quarters, including Ulta Beauty (ULTA) and L'Oreal (LRLCY). In Home, lower replenishment orders from retailers were the culprit. HELE also attributed some supply issues to be an underlying factor.
• Management admitted that it was disappointed in its performance and would act immediately to reset its business, essentially initiating two restructuring programs simultaneously. Even though troubling demand dynamics played a role, this reset primarily led to HELE's slashed FY25 earnings outlook. The company now expects EPS of $7.00-7.50, a massive pullback from its initial $8.70-9.20 forecast.
• Meanwhile, stubborn economic headwinds led to HELE's reduced sales estimate of $1.89-1.94 bln from $1.965-2.025 bln. The company's updated segment growth targets paint an alarming picture of how quickly demand has pulled back. HELE changed its Home & Outdoor growth target to negative 1.0-3.0% from positive +1.0-4.0%. Additionally, Beauty & Wellness sales are now set to fall by as much as 8.0% compared to a worst-case scenario of negative 4.5%.

HELE's Q1 report resulted from several headwinds mixing with the most apparent problem: inflation. Higher prices have hindered HELE's growth for many consecutive quarters. However, even as disinflationary forces take hold, with inflation lasting so long, prices merely rising at a slower pace are not enough to prevent consumers from constantly cutting items from their budgets. With shares now at 2014 levels, today's sell-off may seem like an overreaction. Still, it will likely take a few quarters of noticeable recovery signs before investors feel comfortable that HELE's business reset and restructuring are sufficient to reignite growth.