Story Stocks^®

When Starbucks (SBUX) reported Q3 results in late July, there was some hope that sales trends were beginning to stabilize and that the coffee chain's turnaround plan was starting to take hold as Q3 global comparable store sales improved to -3% from -4% in Q2. Unfortunately, the modest comp improvement was just a mirage as sales trends deteriorated further in Q4, indicating that its expanded range of new menu offerings and increased in-app promotional activity have fizzled out. 

• SBUX's Q4 EPS, revenue, and comp guidance fell flat, badly missing expectations and illustrating how tall of a task new CEO Brian Niccol has in front of him. That challenge isn't limited to just one key market, either, as U.S. comps declined by 6% compared to last quarter's 2% drop, while China comparable store sales sank by 14%, matching the decrease in Q2.
• Mr. Niccol, who previously served as CEO of Chipotle Mexican Grill (CMG), officially took the helm of SBUX on September 9, 2024, replacing Laxman Narasimham. Given Niccol's impressive track record at CMG -- revenue doubled, and profits increased nearly sevenfold under his six-year tenure -- there's a hope and expectation that he can repeat that success at SBUX. One major challenge he's facing is to reconnect with the lower-frequency customer who has cut pricier SBUX coffee out of their budgets.
• That will be easier said than done, but he's confident that his experience in building brands -- and, in this case, rebuilding brands -- will help right the ship as SBUX shifts its marketing strategy to focus on all customers, rather than just Rewards customers. Better store execution during the morning rush, such as ensuring all drinks and food are on time, improving digital capabilities, and elevating the in-store experience to differentiate between to-go and for-here service are other pillars of his U.S. turnaround plan.
• In China, the challenge is two-fold. First, SBUX is contending with an increasingly competitive market that's being flooded with new coffee shops and pick-up kiosks, leading to intense price pressures. Second, macroeconomic headwinds have put a strain on discretionary spending trends, similar to the U.S. While fixing the U.S. market is Niccol's first priority, China is SBUX's second largest market, and under Mr. Narasimham's leadership, the company had plans to expand its store count to 9,000 units by 2025.
• There's less clarity around the turnaround plan for China, but it wouldn't be surprising if SBUX scales back on its aggressive expansion plans, at least until the U.S. market is in much better shape. The timeframe for this turnaround is also uncertain, but it could be several quarters before SBUX's financials begin to reflect meaningful improvements. On that note, the company also suspended its FY25 guidance, essentially giving Mr. Niccol a clean slate to work with heading into next fiscal year.

Despite the very gloomy Q4 outlook, shares of SBUX are displaying some resilience today, presumably because the market is viewing Q4 as a "kitchen sink quarter" that could represent a bottom in this rough period. That could very well be the case and Niccol's track record of success offers reason to believe that better days are indeed ahead, but it certainly won't be an overnight fix.