Story Stocks^®

It was business as usual for Paychex (PAYX +3%) in Q1 (Aug), delivering another narrow earnings beat on in-line revenue growth. The payroll services and human capital management firm has a rich history of similar headline numbers each quarter. Since this builds in a certain expectation, other variables often influence subsequent price action. Guidance plays a dominant role, especially in today's uncertain environment, clouded by the usual headwinds of inflation and high interest rates. However, operating on the labor side of the market, a tight jobs market has also created hurdles for PAYX. Therefore, when stacked against this backdrop, PAYX reiterating its initial FY25 (May) guidance was sufficient to propel its stock to new one-year highs today. Today's job openings data coming in ahead of expectations also produced a tailwind.

• PAYX's 1.8% adjusted EPS growth yr/yr to $1.16 and 2.5% revenue growth to $1.32 bln underperformed the company's FY25 growth targets of +5.0-7.0% and +4.0-5.5%, respectively. However, management alerted investors last quarter that Q1 would lag due to two main headwinds.
  • The first was a lower contribution from PAYX's Employee Retention Tax Credit (ERTC) service. The second was timing; PAYX experienced one less processing day in Q1 than in the year-ago period. The headwinds slashed over 400 bps off PAYX's top line in the quarter, with the impact seeping into its bottom line.
• PAYX's Management Solutions segment inched just 1% higher yr/yr to $961.7 mln, reflecting the ERTC headwind. However, the number of clients served still expanded in the quarter. Meanwhile, Professional Employer Organization and Insurance Solutions shined, jumping 7% to $319.3 mln due to worksite employee growth.
• Over the immediate term, PAYX is projecting accelerating revenue growth of +4-5% in Q2 (Nov) as the headwind from the expiration of the ERTC program eases. While PAYX anticipates moderate growth across its core small and medium-sized business (SMB) landscape, it continues to notice businesses looking for ways to drive efficiency, giving PAYX prime growth opportunities. PAYX is also actively implementing generative AI to differentiate its tools from competitors and drive additional efficiency gains for clients.
• Alongside guidance, PAYX's comments can also sway investor sentiment. CEO John Gibson remarked that the labor market is gradually returning to pre-pandemic levels while wage inflation is moderating. These are positive developments, particularly for SMBs, which are more sensitive to economic trends than larger enterprises. It was also an encouraging comment, given that PAYX noticed soft close rates and decision-making delays across the business landscape last quarter.

PAYX's Q1 report was sound, putting up consistent numbers despite lingering headwinds. With these challenges continuing to moderate while payrolls, HR functions, and various regulations grow more complex, SMBs will likely keep outsourcing these aspects of their business, putting PAYX in a firm position to maintain steady growth over the long term.