Story Stocks^®

Masonite International (DOOR) opened the door to the M&A market this morning, announcing its intention to acquire impact-resistant frame window and door maker PGT Inc. (PGTI) in a cash-and-stock deal valued at $3.0 bln. The transaction amounts to $41/share with PGTI shareholders receiving $33.50 in cash and $7.50 in common stock of DOOR, which represents a fairly modest premium of about 14% over last Friday's closing price. However, PGTI had already doubled in price on a year-to-date basis and reached all-time highs last Thursday, leaving less room for DOOR to offer an attractive price that it would be comfortable with.

• Still, DOOR is selling off sharply in the wake of this news even though it's only paying about 8x next year's earnings for PGTI. The main issue is that the company is partly financing the deal with new debt and/or equity, negatively affecting its EPS. Furthermore, investors may be questioning the timing of making a big splash in the M&A market when the company already has plenty on its plate and is trying to turn its own business around. 
• In each of the past two quarters, DOOR's revenue has declined on a yr/yr basis, following flat revenue in 1Q23. During its Q3 earnings call in early November, DOOR noted that rising mortgage rates were continuing to put pressure on its end markets. The company saw "considerably softer demand" in both the new construction and the repair and remodeling markets, causing EPS and revenue to fall by 19% and 3.5%, respectively.
• Perhaps market participants would feel a little more comfortable if DOOR's business was starting to turn a corner and it could completely focus its attention on integrating the acquisition. Overall, though, we do believe that PGTI is a good fit for DOOR from a strategic and financial standpoint.
• PGTI's heavy-duty aluminum and vinyl frames are made to withstand hurricane-force winds and will nicely complement DOOR's more traditional interior and exterior residential doors. While PGTI has also been impacted by higher mortgage rates, its business has been a little more resilient.
  • Last quarter, sales in the southeast segment grew by 5% to a record of $303 mln with strength in new construction (+6%) and repair and remodeling (+5%). 
• A broader, more diversified product portfolio is a key positive to this deal, but DOOR also expects to realize approximately $100 mln in annual synergies over the next several years due to a combination of cost-saving and sales growth opportunities.
  • In particular, the company should experience more cross-selling opportunities as it sells to a larger, more diverse customer base. Importantly, the transaction is expected to be accretive to DOOR's EPS in the first full year of ownership and accelerate thereafter, despite the use of new equity and/or debt to finance it.

Although the idea of taking on more risk in an environment that's already very challenging isn't going over very well today, we do believe the acquisition could ultimately provide DOOR with a much-needed growth catalyst, especially if easing rates provide the business with a jumpstart.